About Us

At First State Insurance, we answer our phones, provide good insurance advice, follow through with your requests and treat you like family. Outstanding Customer Service is not just a motto here. We strive daily to be the type of insurance company that you will enjoy doing business with and will want to send us your friends.

Our independent agents have over 100 years of combined experience. We’ll use our expertise to help you find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to fit your needs. We’ll research rates and coverage from top-rated insurance companies to find the best rates and plans for you. We do the insurance shopping and comparing for you to save you time and money!


Call or stop by to meet one of our agents to discuss how we can help you with your personal or business insurance needs.

In need of insurance in Indiana? Get a free quote! 
Middlebury: 574-825-5458
Goshen: 574-534-2686
Elkhart: 574-266-7892



First State Insurance Agency, Inc.  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy